Friday, 24 August 2018

We Come Not to Praise But to Bury, The Legacy of Malcolm Turnbull, Medium, 24 August, 2018.

Image result for medium



We Come not to Praise But to Bury

The Terrible Legacy of Malcolm Turnbull


Image courtesy BBC

Those Whom the Gods Would Destroy

The Coverage

Malcolm Turnbull’s Day of Reckoning has arrived.
He could have left with dignity ten days ago; doctors advice, spend more time with his grandchildren.
But this hapless Prime Minister, with his Party Room in revolt, cannot even manage his own political death.
A very bad loser, he may well end up taking down the entire government.
Here’s what the papers are saying:
The Australian: Turnbull’s house of cards crumbles
Malcolm Turnbull has threatened to strip the government of its majority in the parliament and force an early election.

Courtesy The Guardian

The Guardian: Turnbull shows no mercy as warring Liberals tear out the party’s heart and soul
Australian politics has found new depths to plumb. “It’s been olive branch after olive branch. Eventually they will shove that olive branch up his arse.”
As premonitions go, it was apposite. That is precisely what happened, and then some.
The New Daily: Madness: Turnbull plays final card to stay on as PM
Australia will get a new prime minister this Friday. No matter who it is, the damage to the government over the past week is beyond repair.
In an extraordinary gamble to stay in power, Malcolm Turnbull has attacked his leadership rival Peter Dutton as possibly ineligible to be prime minister, and demanded written proof of party room discontent.
ABC: Stable government?
Malcolm Turnbull, besieged by his own party colleagues, has strapped explosive devices to himself and dared them to come and get him.


The Disastrous Legacy

With the Media baying for blood, Malcolm Turnbull is leaving not just a divided Party but a divided country.
The evil that men do lives after them.

Image Courtesy Moddb

A poor loser, in his final hours Turnbull is lashing out, blaming everybody but himself, and threatening to destroy his government rather than hand over the reigns of power.
All of this is occurring in front of the cameras he cannot resist; the psychodrama and the theatre of political suicide.
Now is the time to look at the tragedy of arguably the worst Prime Minister in Australian history.
Everyone will have their own list.
Here are but a few:

The National Broadband Network — NBN

The NBN was a government fiasco which forced by law millions of Australians onto an inferior broadband network, destroying businesses and individual creativity alike.
While the rest of the world is forging online, Australia now has by a number of measures the worst and most expensive internet in the world.
Described as the greatest infrastructure debacle in Australian history, with costs which may run as high as $90billion.
Despite being Communications Minister for two years, Turnbull has refused to accept responsibility. Or to apologise to the NBN’s long suffering customers.
Now there’s a business model: pass a law forcing you to downgrade your technology to medieval times.

Indigenous Relations: Constitutional Recognition



Millions of taxpayer dollars vanished in the push for Constitutional Recognition of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islanders.
The hopes, energies and aspirations of Australia’s indigenous populations were absorbed in an elaborate bureaucratic farce.
Despite all the talk, in the end Turnbull did not even have the courtesy to attend the National Constitutional Convention or listen in person to the Uluru Statement From The Heart.
Shortly afterwards, the government dismissed the whole idea of constitutional change via press release, not even bothering to inform or consult the main players.
It was a brutal colonialist contempt towards the indigenous populations, now increasingly disengaged from the mainstream as the country undergoes rapid demographic transformation.

Image Courtesy ABC

Same Sex Marriage

In a deliberate attempt to poison the public square and to distract the attention of Australians from their own falling living standards and the spectacular incompetence of his government, Malcolm Turnbull spearheaded a national plebiscite costing an estimated $122 million.
Day after day, month after month, journalists could think of nothing else. Every question directed at a politician was seen through a rainbow prism. Are you a progressive? Or are you not?
While there was a 62% yes vote celebrated as a victory, the process left the country deeply divided.
The question read: “Should the law be changed to allow same-sex couples to marry?” Ballots were posted to Australia’s 16 million registered voters.
Religious minorities are now more isolated than ever.
For a start Muslims are more convinced than ever that the sooner the Caliphate arrives the better. For them the sight of two men, or two women, kissing is a shocking anathema flying in the face of Allah’s will, an example of the putrid cesspool the infidels have created for themselves.


Promised religious protections never arrived.
Australians, in their own gruff indifferent way, were once more tolerant than they are now: “I don’t care who you fuck as long as you’re not fucking me.”
Now they have been forced to think about things they really don’t want to think about. And humans being humans, all they can think about are the pink bits. They do what?
The gay movement wasn’t born ouit of a desire to live behind a white picket fence. But that’s where it’s ended, in a marriage, just like the those raving heterosexuals nextdoor.
The government is inept. It does nothing well. It certainly doesn’t do marriage well. It should get out of our lives.


Marriage, a multi-billion dollar cash cow for lawyers because of the nation’s atrocious divorce courts, now has rich new pickings.
They’re my Barbara Streisand records!!
No they’re not, they’mine.
Where does it all end?
Certificates for Outstanding Performance at an Orgy, Best in the Over-60s Category, Distinguished Courage Medals for Facing the World Alone.
These people, the overlords, their henchmen and henchwomen, never stop in their appropriation of private space.
Thousands of hours of media time, countless stories for and against, the stirring up of intense emotions over a social justice issue which could have been resolved in five minutes and which the government created in the first place, turning people’s private lives into public theatre for political advantage, even by the standards of Australia’s political class this was a new low.

Losing the Outer Suburbs

The residents of Australia’s outer suburbs have never been more disengaged from the nation’s political processes.

Image Courtesy ABC

They don’t give a fuck about me so why should I give a fuck about them?” Tradie. Public Bar. The Illawarra.
One of the golden rules of Australian politics is that no party can form government without winning seats in the outer suburbs and hinterland of our major cities.

Ian Waldie/Getty Images

Former leader of the Labor Party and former Prime Ministerial contender Mark Latham, now a vicious critic of both sides of parliament, argues that these are the key marginal electorates that make or break political leaders.
“Why is the Prime Minister so unpopular in these areas? It’s not just his aloof manner and Harbourside Mansion reputation.
“His policies are hurting working families battling away on the fringe of our major cities.The real problem is not in the relative distribution of incomes in Australia. It’s the way in which flawed government policies are hurting ALL income earners.
“Turnbull’s policies have failed for people living on the edge of our major cities, so not surprisingly, they don’t want him as our Prime Minister. Mark Latham, The Daily Telegraph, 1 August 2018.

In newer suburbs people prefer to remove trees rather than plant them. Photo: Paul Rovere. Domain.

Latham names several touchstone issues:
  1. The housing affordability crisis, due to new arrivals under Big Australia immigration flooding the housing market.
  2. Increased energy prices, as Australia goes further down the path of putting all our eggs in the renewables basket.
  3. Income tax bracket creep, with Turnbull giving higher priority to corporate tax cuts than an immediate plan for substantial personal tax cuts.
  4. Sluggish wage growth, again caused by Big Australia immigration that has flooded the labour market and given two-thirds of new jobs to newly arrived migrants.

Epitaph

There are so many low points to Turnbull’s prime ministership it is difficult to count them all. Plunging educational outcomes, a collapsing underclass and a dispirited nation are just some.
While strutting the political stage in front of a thousand cameras, many of Turnbull’s announcements were the leitmotifs of the bureaucratic left.

Courtesy God Is An Astronaut

At the same time he dragged the country closer to totalitarianism, with his attacks on journalists and free speech, his massive expansion of surveillance of the population, and his gifting of large amounts of money to Australia’s ultra-secretive and essentially unaccountable national security agencies.
The hidden powers of Australian governance.
There are no saviours of democracy on the horizon. Rather, around the world we see a new authoritarianism that is always anti-democratic in practice, populist in appeal, nationalist in sentiment, fascist in sympathy, criminal in disposition, tending to spew a poisonous rhetoric aimed against refugees, Muslims, and increasingly Jews, and hostile to truth and those who speak it, most particularly journalists to the point, sometimes, of murder. Richard Flanagan.
This is the point Turnbull brought to the country to.
The true tragedy of Turnbull’s failed Prime-ministership is that the country stands at a precipice, facing increasing social division, crumbling services, and a plummeting place in the world.
A once plucky, optimistic, industrious country is happy no longer.

Image Courtesy Australiance

And nobody believes a word that comes out of the mouths of their elected representatives.
With Australians experiencing a drift towards totalitarianism in their daily lives, evident in everything from ridiculous if not insane levels of regulation to excessive micro-policing, a growing intolerance of divergent views and bureaucratic and political contempt for the views of ordinary people, there could be no worse time for a loss of faith in democracy.


Thursday, 23 August 2018

Australia's Assault on Freedom of Speech: The Terrible Legacy of Malcolm Turnbull, Medium, 23 August, 2018.

Image result for medium

Australia’s Assault on Freedom of Speech

The Terrible Legacy of Malcolm Turnbull

Let Slip the Dogs of War: Coverage

The word “crisis” is bandied about a lot in discussing Australian politics right this minute.
Nothing the present batch of oligarchs could do to manipulate, suppress or control the media has worked.
Except when it comes down to warfare.
The media hunt in packs, they cannot package a story more complex than a two-horse race, and the battle is on, unto death.
A cruising white shark called Peter Dutton is battle hardened enough to take down the princeling Malcolm Turnbull, arguably the worst Prime Minister in Australian history.
And take him down he will.
That this fowl deed shall smell above the earth with carrion men, groaning for burial. William Shakespeare.
The Daily Telegraph: The Panic Dutton
Would be leader launches campaign of chaos against PM.
The Australian: D-Day for Malcolm Turnbull as key allies desert
Malcolm Turnbull is expected to face his second leadership challenge within 48 hours today. Dogged by leadership speculation and humiliation, Malcolm Turnbull couldn’t escape the debilitating fog of instability.
The Guardian: Liberals in chaos
Dutton backers launch late-night attack on Dutton, hoping to trigger second spill
The New Daily: Dutton camp botches shadowy second strike
Supporters of prime ministerial hopeful Peter Dutton may still force another vote.

Turnbull’s Assault on Freedom of Speech.

With Malcolm Turnbull’s Prime Ministership now terminal, it is appropriate to use this moment of chaos to reflect back on the fiasco Australia’s 39th Prime Minister leaves behind: not just a divided Party but a divided nation.
His legacy will impact on Australian citizens for decades to come.
Malcolm Turnbull did more to destroy freedom of speech than any other Prime Minister in Australian history; encouraging a conformist media and a dumbed down population. It has been deeply irresponsible.
Australian media divides into two camps, left and right.
But the problem with the so-called Liberals, who are the conservatives in Australia, is that almost without exception they are hostage to their departments.
And the Deep State is now deeply left.
So people vote for a conservative politician, and get nothing but bureaucratic agendas, all the usual touchstones of the so-called “progressives”: gay marriage, refugees, climate change, female empowerment, the evils of racism and the church.
Legislation pushed through by the Australian government earlier this year under the guise of national security, allowing for journalists and whistle-blowers to be jailed for up to 20 years, was only one of a string of assaults limiting press freedom.
For the truth must never out.
The falling Turnbull government treated the public like fools. And now comes the Judgement Day.

The Panopticon

Image courtesy Imgur
The panopticon must not be understood as a dream building; it is the diagram of a mechanism of power reduced to its ideal form. Michel Foucault, Crime and Punishment.
The government knew from international research that introducing the panopticon, universal surveillance, would have a devastating impact on Australian culture.
When people know they are being watched, they behave differently. Dissent is stifled, conformity becomes the norm, populations easier to manage.
In parallel, the targeting and surveillance of journalists has reached unprecedented levels and is having a profound impact on the art and practice of journalism.
Try writing something critical of government authorities and security agencies when you know every keystroke is being followed and the information passed up the food chain to some of the very people you may have good reason to regard as entirely untrustworthy.
Image Courtesy DC Universe Online
Surveillance has already moved well beyond the military and government objectives of creating a compliant population. The drift from participatory democracy to oligarchy to totalitarian state is well in play. The public are being extremely poorly served.
A dishonest and incompetent government is a paranoid government. The truth must never out.

Persons of Interest

Journalists are now POIs (Persons of Interest) under the Australian Security Intelligence Organisation (ASIO) Act.
The tranches of anti-journalist legislation include the National Security Legislation Amendment Act (№1) 2014, which introduced jail terms of up to 10 years for journalists who disclosed what are known as SIOs, Secret Intelligence Operations. Who decides what an SIO is? They do.
In the same year, the Counter-Terrorism Legislation Amendment (Foreign Fighters) Act provided for journalists to be jailed for up to 10 years for publishing news reports or ads that might help terrorists recruit. And in 2015, the Data Retention Act (The Telecommunications [Interception and Access] Amendment [Data Retention] Act 2015) permitted police to access journalists’ metadata that could reveal their confidential sources.
Although Australia’s plethora of ultra-secretive national security agencies have a poor reputation and a troubled history, the current generation of conservatives, and in particular Malcolm Turnbull, have seen fit to greatly expand both their funding and their power.

To Understand the Present Look at the Past

The literature on Australia’s ultra-secretive security agencies is sparse.
Yet there is more than enough to indicate serious problems, including excessive surveillance, extensive manipulation of the media, and the spread through the government of the traditional Defence Department attitude towards journalists — that they are public enemy number one, to be shut down or shut up.
The most significant texts include David McKnight’s Australia’s Spies and their Secrets, Meredith Burgmann’s Dirty Secrets: Our ASIO Files and Michael Tubbs’ ASIO: The Enemy Within.
Once upon a time, to think one was under surveillance was viewed as a clear sign of madness. These books demonstrate one thing: if you think you are under surveillance, you almost certainly are. The typical Australian shrug off, “don’t be ridiculous, you’re not that important”, simply does not hold.
My own experience came post-retirement. Returning from several years in Asia, I was struck by the dilapidated state of Australia in contrast to the bustling, dynamic places I had lived in. And so began work on a book initially titled Workers’ Paradise Lost.
But it was impossible to ignore the biggest story of the day, terror, with then-Prime Minister Tony Abbott having abandoned good government in favour of terrifying the population, pounding on about “the death cult” at every opportunity to every news outlet he could. This was despite having been repeatedly warned by terror-messaging experts that his terminology was counterproductive, arousing interest and attracting recruits to Islamic State. Ultra-violence cuts through.
And thus came about the book: Terror in Australia: Workers’ Paradise Lost.
The element that caused most offence was in a strange sense a surface one.
Every single police strike force and terror operation conducted under the Abbott government was named with a pro-jihad tag.
At first, this just seemed completely implausible.
How could this possibly be so?
But there they were — the extremely well-paid leaders of national security agencies up there in front of the cameras triumphantly promoting their latest operation, all of which were named after something any Muslim, with that culture’s well-honed sense of historical grievance, could decipher.
Some of them were so obvious it was difficult to understand why nobody had raised the alarm before.
Here are just a few:
Counter-Terrorism Operation Amberd: Launched straight after Anzac Day in 2015. Amberd is in Armenia and 2015 was the centenary of the largest massacre of Christians in history, 1.5 million.
Jericho Waterfront Taskforce: Jericho was one of the most successful caliphates in history.
Operation Polo: Marco Polo, often known simply as Polo, was one of history’s most famous critics of Islam.
Operation Coulter. Ann Coulter is an infamous American columnist best known for her comment: “Not all Muslims are terrorists, but all terrorists are Muslim.”
And so it went.
When quizzed, the answer from the Australian Federal Police was so bizarre as to be instructive. The government, they claimed, had nothing to do with the naming of task force and counter-terror operations. Tony Abbott’s office did not respond.

Unadulterated Bastardry

From that moment on, I felt under intense, intrusive and intimidatory surveillance.
Some of the most truly egregious legislation passed by the Abbott and Turnbull governments involved so-called Journalist Information Warrants. These allow access to journalists’ data by more than 20 government departments.
The measures had nothing to do with counterterrorism, the lie under which the public had been sold the pup.
As the MEAA journalist’s union records in its excellent report, Criminalising the Truth, Suppressing the Right to Know (May 2016), the Journalist Information Warrant scheme was introduced without consultation with the profession and operates entirely in secret. Journalists are not informed if a warrant is taken out against them and if by some means discover that one has been taken out against them, will be jailed if they publicise the fact. Each warrant can scope the entire cache of telecommunications for the previous two years, trawling through the journalist’s metadata in the hunt for sources.
The laws are now so tight that it becomes a question of how any journalist can write about security operations, or even their own surveillance, without being imprisoned.
I chose to use novelistic techniques. The central character in my last two books is a dishevelled retired reporter with a swirling head and a wild imagination called “Old Alex”.
And, as Alex speculates in Hideout in the Apocalypse:
“Could someone who first began publishing pieces of journalism in the 1970s and had just written a book called Terror in Australia: Workers’ Paradise Lostpossibly be the subject of a Journalist Information Warrant? Or was it illegal to even speculate? It was mind-boggling stuff.”
The problem with government secrecy is that not only does injustice and malfeasance grow in darkness, but suspicion and distrust spreads every which way.
ASIO and other national security agencies continue to recruit from the nation’s universities. Many of the nation’s senior bureaucrats and politicians were students when these agencies were at their most active.
Are they really working for us? Or are they working for them?

Adapted for Medium from a piece originally published in Pearls and Irritations.
John Stapleton worked as a staff reporter at The Sydney Morning Herald and The Australian for more than 20 years. His latest book, Hideout in the Apocalypse, is about surveillance and the crushing of Australia’s larrikin spirit.
A collection of his journalism is being constructed here

Related Stories on Medium

RELATED STORIES ON MEDIUM: