Tuesday, 22 January 2019

Phfen Shock: Yearning for the Chasm, A Sense of Place Magazine, 22 January, 2019.


Phfen Shock: Yearning for the Chasm

Dingoes hanging from a dog tree in the Barrington Tops, NSW, Australia. Picture by Nick O’Malley
Phfen Shock. The words kept repeating through his head, although he could find no definition, no logical reason.
That was the sensation, he discovered, when you arrived at a new place expecting welcome, the village beyond the veil, only to discover as you lay awake in the horror hours, that your mind was picking across the valley floor detecting danger.
Giant wombats, larger than any he had seen in other parts of the country, romped in the fading light. Rabbits picked across the disappearing pastures. A few lichen coated apple trees, remnants of the orchards from a century ago, still survived. Around, the deep forest.
His species, born in hostility, was ever alert to threat.
Southern Highlands, NSW.
It was the shock of somewhere new, somewhere different. Where, when you entered a new valley, even a neighbouring valley, it took time to determine where the threats lay. Unseen. Lurking. Ready to strike. Born in dangerous times in a dangerous world. Surrounded by malevolence. By those who did not wish you well.
He had found himself there, one dark and immutable period, by happenstance, perched above that strange valley. House sitting a farm. Two useless dogs, three donkeys, four chooks. And a rooster.
He expected to enter a period of enormous creativity, and instead curled into a ball ready to die. The smallest target possible. Invisible to the roving forces. He did not trust any of them. Could in an instant become oceanic. Invisible. Inchoate. All at sea. And entirely undetectable.

A Screen He Could Not Enter

Courtesy Southern Highlands Photographic Society
It was pretty but unlovely, that valley with the bracken edging across the pastures and the surrounding forest closing in.
Cleared at enormous human effort, once an orchard with thousands of trees, planted by one loving, hard working, damaged family all those years ago; there house, the mud dab house still intact.
He didn’t, at first, understand why the place was so unsettling.
It was only when he heard the stories he began to understand.
Why it felt as if some tragedy had destroyed the place, and yet there it was, a picturesque valley century on from disaster, when a fireball swept down through the valley and destroyed everything, everything they had ever worked for, all in minutes.

The Family Never Recovered

The patriarch died a broken man. The matriarch died brokenhearted. The children scattered across the Highlands.
And even now, all these years later, with the orchard destroyed and the surrounding forest reclaiming the land from humans, he could feel the tragedy; everything these people had worked for, the lives they had built in this remote place through such remarkable industry, disappearing in an instant. A whole way of life gone, just in an instant.

The Primordial Valley

Instead of being industrious, he just went into some sort of profound shock.
There were times he could hear them thinking, out there. And others when his mind rooted around for threat, and they gathered there in their bored ranches, more worried, like all good public servants, about their contracts than the target or the task at hand.
Days passed without pen in hand. The record broken.
A massacre in Afghanistan. 53 dead on first reports. Promptly disappeared from the consciousness of all but the immediate families and neighbours. In a land used to tragedy.
Pedestrians were mowed down in Toronto. The mayor promptly claimed the city proud of its diversity. More lies. The same as Australia. Lie after lie after lie to defend a failed theory. Until those who knew the truth, how this engineered debacle had come about, had all died, been eliminated, or were in retreat.
Now, the machines were difficult if not impossible to detect. Invisible drones. Micro-cameras. Who knew if they had given up, or simply withdrawn to a safer distance.
Once they set the inflammation in place, it remained, even if the disease, the mismanagement of the nation, the mismanagement of the agencies, the brutal assassinations, the misuse of power, the persecution of the people, no longer presented in his immediate life.
But there it was, a mystery. His mind swept across an unmarked valley. Primordial in nature. Fabulous in intent. Complex as only machines could be; as if they, too, had sown organic machines across the galaxies and this was just one fine reach, far, far away.

To quote esteemed Australian author Richard Flanagan

Our politics . . . dreadful, a black comedy pregnant with collapse, its actors exhausted, without imagination or courage or principle, solely obsessed with pillaging the tawdry jewels of office and fleeing into distant sinecures as ambassadors or high commissioners, or with paid up Chinese board posts, while outside the city burns.
Our society grows increasingly more unequal, more disenfranchised, angrier, more fearful. Our institutions are frayed. Our polity is discredited, and almost daily discredits itself further. Our screens are filled with a preening peloton of potential leaders, but nowhere is there to be found leadership.
Holderlin, the great 19th century poet, wrote of the “mysterious yearning toward the chasm” that can overtake nations. Increasingly, one can sense that yearning in the overly heated rhetoric of some Australian politicians and commentators. That yearning can overtake Australia as easily as it has many other countries, damaging our democratic institutions, our freedoms and our values.

A Mysterious Injustice: A Place Where No One cared

He was rising from the ether, being reborn, marking out territory. He was defying the worst the society had to offer. He was carried through his own mysterious yearning. And then away, away, as if he could not focus, as if he could not stay intent on one narrow grievance, as if the gods were welcoming him to a safer place.
While all around lay a mysterious injustice. A place where no one cared. No one took any pride. Where the shops were dilapidated, as the country sank into Third World status.
On a trip to Sydney, that morning, the only Australian accent he heard were the housos at Gavin’s cafe in Redfern.
They were checking the value of a collection of stolen Ray Bans on their equally stolen iPad.
Working out how long they would take to sell. How long it would take to score. The days were short. They were not comfortable outside. Inside their cluttered, dilapidated, filthy Housing Department flats, equally uncomfortable. There was always someone screaming, shouting abuse. There was always someone trying to score. There were never enough drugs. Not enough drugs in the world.
The Block, Redfern.
The collapse of the underclass, the surest sign of a sick society, was well advanced.
And all around, no one hoped. Sydney had become the worst city in the country. Crowded, bogged, grasping, vicious, and they were led by the greediest, shallowest, most vicious leader the country had ever seen. For the despair of the country led directly from the arrogance at the top.
Old Alex drove, like so many, straight back out of town, away from the city he had once loved so much, through crowded highways, past derelict shops.

Back to the Primordial Valley

To be watched, he assumed, by the surveillance machines. As they always watched. Invisible. Silence. Seemingly eternal.
They were being monitored, there on the remotest outposts of human thought.
Sometimes, he thought, the humans would have been better. At least he could hear their thoughts.
Even in this place, the bastardry of the government knew no bounds.
Most mysterious of all, as the country drove ever more rapidly backwards, ever closer to the chasm, was that nobody cared.
An unforgivable death in an ancient stream.
What was this world we had entered so abruptly?

Wednesday, 16 January 2019

World Press Photographer Jailed in Chinese Crackdown: The Photography of Lu Guang, A Sense of Place Magazine, 16 January, 2019.


World Press Photographer Jailed in Chinese Crackdown

The Photography of Lu Guang

Lu Guang picked up a camera for the first time in 1980, still a teenager. He was a factory worker in his hometown of Yongkang in China’s Zhejiang Province.
After studying in Beijing he became a freelance photographer in 1993, primarily focusing on documentary projects in China.
From humble beginnings, as a multi-award winner Lu Guang and his powerful images became world famous. He focused on some of the most significant social, health, and environmental issues facing China today.
His photographic work includes stories on gold diggers, local coal miners, the SARS epidemic, drug addiction along the Sino-Burmese border, Aids villages in Henan Province, the environmental impact of the Qinghai-Tibet railway, industrial pollution and disease.
Lu Huang disappeared in November, 2018, while visiting China. Initially there were fears he had been killed by the Chinese officials.
He joins a number of other prominent people who have disappeared or arrested in China over the past year.
Children in the orphanage ‘Home of Care and Love’ curl up against each other to sleep.
Yanan Wang of Associated Press writes:
It’s not uncommon for individuals who speak out against the government to disappear in China, but the scope of the “disappeared” has expanded since President Xi Jinping came to power in 2013.
Not only dissidents and activists, but also high-level officials, Marxists, foreigners and even a movie star — people who never publicly opposed the ruling Communist Party — have been whisked away by police to unknown destinations.
The widening dragnet throws into stark relief the lengths to which Xi’s administration is willing to go to maintain its control and authority.

The Crying Light

A family of five children in 2005. They had emigrated from the Ningxia Hui Autonomous Region to Inner Mongolia to find work in the Heilonggui industrial district.
In December The New York Times reported that he was still alive but had been arrested in Kashgar — an ancient city in southern Xinjiang that has been at the centre government crackdown on Uyghurs, Kazakhs and other Muslim minorities.
Authorities are said to be keeping a very close eye on anybody approaching the camps.
His wife Xu says she still doesn’t know why Lu has been arrested and says that the police haven’t provided a written notice confirming the detention.
She tweeted: “Family members have already entrusted lawyers to contact the case-handling authorities, and they have not been allowed to meet with Lu Guang, nor have they obtained any formal written procedures.”
Robert Pledge, co-founder of Contact Press Images, a photojournalism agency, wrote in The New York Times:
“Lu Guang is a deeply concerned citizen. He works almost solely in China, for both linguistic and cultural reasons. His photographs have depicted some of the harsher sides of life in China — AIDS, environmental destruction, pollution and poverty.
Many factories have been moved from the country’s east to its central and western parts. Employees work in the dust.
“Lu Guang . . . has been my friend for more than 15 years. I’m proud that the agency I co-founded represents and distributes his work. We hope that he will soon be returned to us, safely.”
Lu Guang believes, in the tradition of the great American photo essayist, Eugene Smith:
A photo is a small voice, at best, but sometimes — just sometimes — one photograph or a group of them can lure our senses into awareness.

A Tragedy Previously Hidden

Zhou Mao sold his blood three times in order to raise the money to send his five children to school for one semester. He has been ill for three years, and his children have now left school to take care of him.
After moving to New York, he continued to document aspects of the country the Chinese authorities did not want the world to see.
His haunting work on the Aids villages of China won First Prize in the Contemporary Issues category in the 2004 World Press Photo contest.
Gao Rongsheng. 13, at the grave of his parents.
In the mid-1990s, poor peasants in Henan province sold their blood for 50 yuan a pint, enough to buy two bags of fertilizer.
As a result of unsafe procedures, a large number of them were infected with the HIV virus. Many died. In some villages up to 40 percent of the inhabitants are seropositive.
They were isolated from help not just because of extreme poverty but because the existence of AIDS in China was not officially acknowledged.
Even today, many villagers are uncertain whether they are infected and cannot afford a test, which costs 80 yuan. Organized help from local health authorities is underway, but many people do not have the money to go to hospital and are cared for by family and friends.

Journalism Not Propaganda

China Firefighters Zhang Liang and Han Xiaoxiong wade into the polluted water to clean debris from the pump. On 16 July, two pipelines exploded as crude oil was being unloaded from a tanker in the port of Dalian, in northeast China, unleashing a massive oil slick into the Yellow Sea. Firefighter Zhang Liang, 25,, died during clean-up operations.
We live in an era of heavy government and military manipulation of media and public messaging.
The media’s herd mentality, corporate whitewashing and addiction to cheap copy in an age of collapsing revenue streams have transfigured public debate and the societies journalists once served. But the public outcry is zero. Instead once dedicated readers have just switched off.
A younger generation just look at you in disbelief when you tell them journalism was once a respected profession.
While diving to clear debris from the submerged pump responsible for pumping water to firefighting boats, Zhang Liang was caught in an undercurrent and drowned. His colleague Han Xiaoxiong, and later also their instructor Zheng Zhanhong, tried in vain to rescue him.
The mainstream media has itself been complicit in its own demise.
It is now a decade since Nick Davies groundbreaking book Flat Earth Newstore apart the comfortable notions of journalism as a source of truth, compassion, a way of telling ordinary people’s stories and confronting power with truth.
In this terrible era the work of groups like PEN America is more important than ever.
Lu Guang has said: ”Whenever I see these pictures, I feel painful. I have been paying attention to environmental protection and shooting on the environmental protection theme for more than ten years. On July 16, 2010, the pipeline explosion and oil spill accident happened in Dalian. Then I gave close attention to the situation of oil pollution in the ocean.”
PEN America works to ensure that people everywhere have the freedom to create literature, to convey information and ideas, to express their views, and to access the views, ideas, and literatures of others.
We champion the freedom to write, recognizing the power of the word to transform the world.
The organisation describes the disappearance reported detention of Lu Guang as a troubling attack on artistic and journalistic freedom.
That day should have been the date on which Zhang Liang and his fiancée took their wedding pictures. Lu Guang recalled: “On July 19, I arrived in Dalian. I got up at 4 o’clock in the morning on July 20 and shot for three hours along the seaside. At 8:10, I got to the sea area closest to the site of pipeline explosion. In the ocean with thick greasy dirt, I suddenly found two people in the oil contamination. I felt strange and shot several photos with telephoto lens at once. Then I ran towards them.”
Lu has not been heard from since November 3.
Lu was traveling in Xinjiang, the northwestern region of China where over one million Muslims are reportedly being held in “re-education” internment camps where they are being indoctrinated to be loyal to the Chinese Communist Party.
China is facing growing international criticism of its mass detention of Uyghurs and other minorities. After long denying their existence, Beijing has begun to acknowledge it runs the camps, justifying them on the grounds of anti-terrorism.
Lu was scheduled to meet a friend in Sichuan province on November 5 but never showed up. Some sources have since reported that Lu’s wife, Xu Xiaoli, has been informed of Lu’s detention; however, his whereabouts remain unknown, as are the details around his arrest and detention.
The instructor rushed into the greasy dirt to save Zhang Liang. He grasped Zhang’s head and hands; however, it was too slick. He seized Zhang for a while, but loosened at last. Within one minute, Zhang Liang was drowned by the oil and water. My hands began to tremble. A life disappeared in front of me.
The Chinese government has been roundly criticized for its rights-abusive practices in Xinjiang, including the practice of forcibly placing Muslims in “re-education” camps where they are compelled to participate in “patriotic education.”
International estimates vary, but the number of “re-education” internees is believed to number in the hundreds of thousands at least.
In October 2018, the Uyghur Human Rights Project reported that over 200 Uyghur intellectuals had been forcibly taken to the camps, a number that is believed to represent only a fraction of the total. In August of 2018, PEN America noted that Chinese Muslim poet An Ran had apparently been targeted for retaliatory action by authorities, for his statements criticizing governmental policies in Xinjiang.
Lu Guang recalled: “The two soldiers were responsible for the floating boat pump of long-distance water supply system. In order to guarantee putting out the fire and supplying water in the front, they had to clean the sundries on the floating boat pump every day, such as the oil contamination and the sea grass. They had been working for four days continuously since the explosion happened.”
Julie Trebault, the Director of the Artists at Risk Connection at PEN America, says:
Lu’s disappearance is deeply concerning, and we must assume that it is related to his work as a photojournalist, exposing truths about China that the government no doubt would prefer remained hidden.
Dalian, Liaoning, China. A funeral and memorial service is held for Zhang Liang.
Unfortunately, Lu’s case is not unique. The Chinese government has a history of disappearing artists who use their practices as a platform to challenge and critique the regime’s policies. PEN America calls on the Chinese government to disclose Lu Guang’s whereabouts and detention status and to release him immediately.

A Polluted China a Polluted World

March 23, 2008. Laseng Temple has an over 200-year-old history, which includes the study of Mongolian medicines. It was seriously polluted by the surrounding factories, so few pilgrims go there now.
Lu Guang did a considerable amount of work on pollution in China, much of it on commission from Greenpeace.
“Because China’s economy is moving so fast, the pollution is incredibly severe,” he has said. “As I became aware of the pollution as China opened up the western area, I felt that people needed to know about this.”
Material accompanying his work on development and pollution declared:
Most factories in Hainan Industrial Park of Wuhai City in Inner Mongolia are high-energy consuming and high-pollution producing.
China is now the world’s second-largest economy.
Its economic development has consumed lots of energy and generated plenty of pollution.
A habit of directly discharging unprocessed industrial sewage, exhaust gas and waste material has led to pollution of farmlands, grasslands and drinking water as well as the ocean and the air.
Over the past 10 years, factories have been moved from the country’s east to its central and western parts, thus greatly expanding the polluted area and increasing the severity of the the situation.
National Geographic Competition 2018
Although the environmental protection administration has shut down many small enterprises with serious pollution emission, some still continue to discharge contaminants illegally. Some have adopted covert operations, such as releasing the smoke and gas waste at night.
The sewage channel is embedded into the river and ocean for discharging pollution. Western factories have large evaporation ponds to store sewage, but the sewage sinks into the ground, thus polluting the water source.
Minerals, such as coal and iron, are expanded to large-scale predatory strip mine exploitation from the original underground mining.
Grassland has been turned into desert.
Fertile farmland has given way to barren mountains.
Herdsmen no longer have grassland.
Farmers have lost their farms, their own homelands destroyed, thus causing the villagers to become displaced.
Winds carry the exposed coal dust and sand, causing smog. Smog, in turn, forces middle and primary schools to close. Flights get delayed. The highway gets shut down.
The number of hospital patients with respiratory disease goes up. Food and drinking water is polluted, which leads to cancer, so common China has seen the emergence of ‘cancer villages’. China’s environmental pollution has already exerted great threats to the people’s life and security.

The Petition

Disabled Chinese orphans cared for by farmers
Hugh Brownstone, a prominent photographer, filmmaker and writer, has begun a petition on Change.org calling for Lu Guang’s immediate release.
He describes him as an extraordinary photojournalist.
In his appeal Brownstone writes:
Lu Guang has been awarded multiple times by the World Press; won the Henri Nannen Prize for Photojournalism; and received grants from the W. Eugene Smith Memorial Fund, the Prince Claus foundation, and National Geographic.
His work focuses primarily on the social impact of industrialization in China, but it is universal in its applicability — and as art in and of itself. It is filled with humanity.
Sisters prepare to bury their six-year old brother, who has died of AIDS
In this regard, he follows in the footsteps of renowned photographers from France’s Henri Cartier-Bresson to America’s Walker Evans, Dorothea Lange, Gordon Parks, Margaret Bourke White, Elliott Erwitt, and China’s own Fan Ho.

Once upon a time — like 1933 through 1944 — the United States commissioned many of these same photographers to capture the plight of the less fortunate members of its citizenry. The Farm Security Administration under Roy E. Stryker was not afraid of capturing the truth, but rather sought to enlist it in service of the people.
To make life better. Fairer.
A more perfect union.
This is hardly a uniquely American ambition.

Lu Guang’s arrest in China is of no less concern than today’s egregious attacks on the press right here in the U.S. or as far flung as places like Turkey and most recently Saudi Arabia with the government-conducted murder of the journalist Jamal Khashoggi.

This is not a uniquely Chinese issue.

But at the moment Lu Guang’s arrest is a problem only the Chinese can fix. Please join me in requesting that the Chinese government organize his immediate release, safe and unharmed, without restriction. It is, after all, a sign of strength, not weakness, to admit a mistake and fix it.
There are more prisoners, of course. In China alone, there are currently at least 50 journalists imprisoned for vague reasons.
In the long run, free and objective journalism serves all of us, even if, or precisely because, journalists uncover uncomfortable truths.
To see Hugh Brownstone’s accompanying video or to sign the petition click here.

Lu Guang